Two entries ago we had The Rolling Stones' Sticky Fingers as the first of six great albums that came out in 1971 which produced a Canadian number one — and here's the second. Somehow, it even outsold the Stones and has at least an equal amount of accumulated critical acclaim. Yes, it's yet another big one.
You might say that Carole King had it coming. Newly divorced from her husband and collaborator of nearly ten years, she relocated to Laurel Canyon in 1968. As such, she began associating with the likes of Joni Mitchell and James Taylor. Her work became more personal. Her second solo album in the can, she posed for its front cover alongside a slightly out-of-focus cat while lounging around her home barefoot. You can practically smell the scented candles and hear the creaks in the hardwood flooring. You didn't need to listen to a single note to know that this was serious folk-rock.
Of course, there's much more to Tapestry than that. Wikipedia classifies it as both 'soft rock' and 'pop' but that hardly does it justice either. R&B? Sure. Gospel? In places, yeah. Jazz? Jazzy certainly. Genres upon subgenres but the only accurate style is that of 'Carole King'. Duke Ellington was a genre unto himself and so was Traffic and Kate Bush and John Mellancamp and Blur and no doubt many twenty-first century acts I have never heard of before are as well. (Is this me trying to weasel out of having to place a label on King's work? I'd rather not say)
Listening to "It's Too Late" isolated from its parent album 'folk' is just about the last word I'd use to describe it. It's poppy albeit done in a very mature fashion. It has a steady groove. It is not unlike a lot of R&B that came before it and plenty that has come out since. It is the product of a woman who wrote some of the finest pop music of all time for others who has now turned it around on herself. Yes, there is a throughline connecting, say, "The Loco-Motion" to "It's Too Late". (And there's certainly a throughline from The Shirelles' "Will You Love Me Tomorrow" to King's "Will You Love Me Tomorrow") Her writing along with ex Gerry Goffin did a reverse Stock Aitken Waterman: they're work became less moronic as they became more accomplished and successful. Mid-to-late sixties compositions such as "Goin' Back", "Wasn't Born to Follow", "Pleasant Valley Sunday" and "The Porpoise Song" show that the pair could embrace maturity without compromising their deft pop touch.
Maturity is the big takeaway from "It's Too Late". Rather than begging or threatening or an overall sense of being pathetic, the acceptance in King's voice is a refreshing thing to hear. Obviously she didn't just come to this over night and the fact that she sounds like she has a slight cold makes it seem like she had been going through hell up until this point. Some singers are able to make it sound like they're crying but not many have been able to sound like they just stopped. A great many songs and poems have been composed during the first four stages of grief (denial, anger, bargaining, depression) but how many are left to that crucial fifth stage (acceptance)?
(I had been convinced that the line "Still I'm glad for what we had..." had been borrowed by Marvin Gaye on "When Did You Stop Loving Me, When Did I Stop Loving You" from his vindictive yet brilliant 1978 divorce album Here, My Dear only for me to discover that his line was actually "Still I remember some of the good things, baby..."; it's fascinating how reflecting on a broken down relationship can differ from the spirit of wishing a former paramour well all the way to passive-aggressive spite)
Putting aside King maturely coming to terms with the end of a relationship, "It's Too Late" is also just an outstanding single. If not quite as beguiling as Gordon Lightfoot's "If You Could Read My Mind", it is a sturdier pop song that actually reads almost as well as it sounds. If the sixties was a time when young couples rushed into marriages, then the seventies would be when many of them fell apart. Divorce and/or breakup albums would become reasonably commonplace before long. Pop and rock fans had already been fed countless songs of teen heartbreak and so now the onus was on songwriters to offer more insight as to how the love they had went so badly wrong. "It's Too Late" would become one of the foundational numbers of this burgeoning movement.
My mum had a very worn copy of Tapestry that she must've bought in the early seventies. Later, she acquired it on CD which is how I first came to hear it. Imagine my surprise, then, to discover that I already knew every single track. Perhaps she'd played the vinyl when I was young or maybe King's songs were just so damn omnipresent in the culture that I became familiar with them without even knowing it. (That said, I do have clear memories of hearing "You've Got a Friend", although that would also come via Taylor and, much later, The Housemartins) As I have already stated, it is much more musically diverse than it is normally credited. Whatsmore, "It's Too Late" (along with a handful of other tracks) gives it an erroneous reputation as a breakup album. I prefer to think of it as an account of Carole King's life as a single mother in her late twenties. After-all, it's not a Tapestry because it's about one aspect of her life but because it weaves together bits from various parts of it.
Score: 9
Unofficial Score for Tapestry: 9
~~~~~
Con Can
Growing up in the early nineties I became acquainted with "Signs" due to a (possibly?) live version of it by American hair metal band Tesla. Those poor old headbanger bands, eh? So many of them had to pull out the acoustic guitars in order to get that hit single that had eluded them for so many years. Rather than demeaning themselves with a lame love song like Extreme or Mr Big, Tesla went for a classic rock cover and respect to them. It is perhaps with this in mind that I had always assumed Ottawa's Five Man Electrical Band to be metal or proto-metal as well. In reality, they did a bit of everything that falls within the pop-rock spectrum. They won't be coming up in a review of their own but "Signs" was the first of three that came close to reaching number one on RPM and I'll be sure to cover them at least once more in this supplementary space. Though the topic of advertising being annoying and lame is hardly anything new (although maybe it was back in the seventies), 5MEB give it a good go with an easy to learn chorus and a protest song that has remained relevant ever since. It really tells you about the inefficacy of music though: if guitars did indeed "kill fascists" as Woody Guthrie believed, they've had far less luck doing away with evil corporations owning our lives. On an unrelated note, this blog is sponsored by the good people at BoredVPN: watch streaming services from around the world and we promise not to share your personal information with the AI geek who bankrolls us.