Wednesday, 18 November 2026

The Stampeders: "Sweet City Woman"


There have never been bands hailing out of Edmonton going by the names of either The Eskimos or The Elks. Vancouver (and, indeed, the province of British Columbia as a whole) doesn't have a groups called The Lions. The same goes for Saskatchewan and The Roughriders, Winnipeg and The Blue Bombers, Toronto and The Argonauts, Hamilton and The Tiger-Cats, Ottawa and any one of The Rough Riders (yes, them again), The Renegades and The RedBlacks and Montreal and The Alouettes and The Concords. If any of these bands did exist at some point there's a reason no one ever heard of them beyond possibly a one of dive bar gig in Prince George, BC or Kenora, Ontario. (I am, however, prepared to believe there are people in the Maritimes who are convinced there's a group called The Schooners even if nobody has ever heard them or seen them play)

Yet, a trio coming out of my hometown of Calgary decided that the best possible name they could use was The Stampeders. And I get it. Thinking up a decent name for your group is difficult and it can be even more of a challenge to get other members to agree. (Everyone found my suggestion of Hot Dog Day as a good name to be funny but that's as far as it got) Having soured on their original name The Rebounds — yeah, not great — it's easy to imagine members Kim Berly, Rich Dodson and Ronnie King at an impasse before one of them threw up his arms in defeat and said, "Oh hell, let's just go with Stampeders guys". Pick a boring name and stick with it.

Doomed as they may have seemed in borrowing their name from a Canadian Football League club (as well as a successful minor pro hockey club), not to mention the obvious association with the annual Calgary Exhibition and Stampede, The Stampeders became the first major rock act to emerge from Cowtown. You might also say the only major rock act period. (Sorry, Red Autumn Fall and Zuckerbaby) They did so by touring constantly and a move to Toronto probably didn't hurt as well. As if not wishing to disappoint the folk in Hogtown with their provincial name, they were as country-rock in their sound as you can imagine. Luckily, the city that was rapidly becoming the largest in Canada had been the breeding ground for rootsy acts like The Band so there was a receptive audience for them.

Dodson has said that it was the thrill of being in Canada's two major cities that inspired "Sweet City Woman". Being in Montreal for Expo 67 gave him the idea for the "bon, c'est bon, bon, bon..." part that comes out of the first pass of the chorus. Honestly, I assumed they were just singing to the beat, unaware that they were trying French. The rest comes from being a hayseed from a distant town (Calgary's population in the early seventies was just under 400,000 people, peanuts compared to it now as it inches toward two million) caught up in the lights of Yonge Street. (Question: did young western Canadians shit pants the first time they caught a glimpse of Toronto's iconic Sam the Record Man store or am I just projecting?) While I appreciate that Ontario's capital is a major North American city — even if Americans simply have to call it 'Toronto, Canada' — it seems a little quaint to make it seem like it was not unlike being in New York or London or Hong Kong. Then again, this was right around the time my mum moved from her small town to Calgary, a city she found to be enormous so I suppose it's all relative.

In my recent review of Hamilton, Joe Frank and Reynolds' "Don't Pull Your Love", I mention that it would have been better had they gone more in the direction of country music and I feel that "Sweet City Woman" makes the case far better than I ever could. Even with Dodson's banjo (which, fun fact, he borrowed from a Toronto music store!) it's just country enough. Not in your face, cliches-and-all country but enough to keep the folk back in Alberta pleased — not to mention the country fans in Ontario. It's not unlike what The Flying Burrito Brothers would do on their rather overlooked 1971 self-titled album or what the emergent Eagles would do on their debut LP the following year: laid back, a bit country, touches of rock and even kind of groovy. The Nashville machine couldn't have and wouldn't have wanted to have anything to do with "Sweet City Woman" and all the better for it. Nevertheless, Americans liked it enough to give The Stampeders their lone Top 10 hit on the Hot 100. A delight from the off and one that you can easily be singing along with in no time, ruined only slightly by an over-repetitive chorus near the end.

The Stampeders would finish out 1971 with a tour (they would play Calgary's Jubilee Auditorium that September) and they would have their third RPM Top 10 hit with the punchy southern jam "Devil You" (their first, "Carry Me", has already been discussed here). Meanwhile, their namesakes the Calgary Stampeders won their first Grey Cup title since 1948, triumphing 14-10 over the Argonauts. They wouldn't win another until 1992 when Doug Flutie went God mode. My hometown would have to wait even longer for another Calgary act to hit the top of the Canadian charts though I'm not sure most of my fellow citizens cared or even noticed. People really can be insensitive.

Finally, this is the song that gave me the title for this blog. I don't know if rhyming 'tunes' with 'macaroons' is especially brilliant but it is a nice throwback to coconut almond cookies that have largely been forgotten about. I suppose if someone was to do a cover of it now it might altered to...

And she sing in the evening old familiar songs
And she feeds me love and tenderness and macarons

...which won't do at all.

Score: 8

Sunday, 15 November 2026

Hamilton, Joe Frank and Reynolds: "Don't Pull Your Love"


Redemption. Young, up and coming musicians being prostituted out by an evil, faceless record company in order to shill a pop song that they had nothing to do with. It was an opportunity of a sort but there was no reason to believe that anything more would result from T-Bones Dan Hamilton, Joe Frank Corollo and Tommy Reynolds. Indeed, bandmates George Dee, Gene Pello and Richard Torres were never heard from again beyond session work while Judd Hamilton found some success as a screen writer and film executive. Still, give 'em credit: ff the door was left even just a crack open, they managed to barge their way through — and it only took them five years.

The story of Hamilton, Joe Frank and Reynolds ought to be one for us to admire. And it sort of is. Sure, their name is baffling (maybe it's me having a touch of ADHD but a surname followed by a Christian name and then another surname is just wrong; at least one individual behind the cult eighties series Mystery Science Theater 3000 seems to have agreed with me) but they emerged from being pawns to pop stars in their own right. Good for them. Too bad "Don't Pull Your Love" isn't as good as the single they once mimed to on national TV.

As readers of this blog will know, I wasn't especially fond of "No Matter What Shape (Your Stomach's In)". I didn't say so at the time but it reminds me of the sort of token instrumental track bands will add at the last minute to fill out an album. The Wrecking Crew (aka The Real T-Bones) had played on some astonishing Beach Boys tracks that weren't adorned with vocals (which sort of undermines their status as 'Beach Boys tracks') like "Let's Go Away for a While", "Pet Sounds" and "The Nearest Faraway Place" but they weren't at their best on a simple, nondescript jingle for Alka-Seltzer. Say what you will about Hamilton, Joe Frank and Reynolds (aka The Fake T-Bones minus two) but they could've at least had fun with it. Even with all that said, "No Matter What Shape" still holds up better than the present single.

"Don't Pull Your Love" is spirited but there's little else to say about it. The trio of Hamilton, Joe Frank and Reynolds were part of the emerging soft rock movement but they seemed to be backing an especially regressive form of it. They could have further leaned into country-rock which would've been suitable but they merely hint at it. What is clear is their debt to Elvis. Dennis Potter and Frank Lambert apparently had The King in mind when they wrote it but it isn't known if Elvis was even aware of it. As it happens, timing was on the side of HJF&R. While good will remained towards Elvis following his famous comeback in the late sixties, he reverted to mostly dismal music while raking in a fortune as a concert attraction. Elvis impersonators were already a thing but not widespread or prominent so it was left to "Don't Pull Your Love" to be the pop song that if you squinted your eyes — and did the equivalent with your ears — you could just about convince yourself that this was the real thing.

It isn't, unless of course you happen to be fond of mediocre Elvis. On the other hand, the second major hit for GJF&R is somehow that much worse. "Fallin' in Love" is lush and about as mid-seventies as you can get without doing a revamped disco version. It also happened to be their one and only chart topper on the Hot 100. On the RPM listings it came up just short. A small mercy. (There is a nice twist at this point, however. Tommy Reynolds had quit the trio in 1974 but they were contractually obliged to carry on under their original name. So, the band whose roots were in miming to a single they never played on was now performing under the name of a member who was no longer with them. The pop game is a funny old business)

Score: 4

Friday, 13 November 2026

Carole King: "It's Too Late"


Two entries ago we had The Rolling Stones' Sticky Fingers as the first of seven great albums that came out in 1971 which produced a Canadian number one — and here's the second. Somehow, it even outsold the Stones and has at least an equal amount of accumulated critical acclaim. Yes, it's yet another big one.

You might say that Carole King had it coming. Newly divorced from her husband and collaborator of nearly ten years, she relocated to Laurel Canyon in 1968. As such, she began associating with the likes of Joni Mitchell and James Taylor. Her work became more personal. Her second solo album in the can, she posed for its front cover alongside a slightly out-of-focus cat while lounging around her home barefoot. You can practically smell the scented candles and hear the creaks in the hardwood flooring. You didn't need to listen to a single note to know that this was serious folk-rock.

Of course, there's much more to Tapestry than that. Wikipedia classifies it as both 'soft rock' and 'pop' but that hardly does it justice either. R&B? Sure. Gospel? In places, yeah. Jazz? Jazzy certainly. Genres upon subgenres but the only accurate style is that of 'Carole King'. Duke Ellington was a genre unto himself and so was Traffic and Kate Bush and John Mellancamp and Blur and no doubt many twenty-first century acts I have never heard of before are as well. (Is this me trying to weasel out of having to place a label on King's work? I'd rather not say)

Listening to "It's Too Late" isolated from its parent album 'folk' is just about the last word I'd use to describe it. It's poppy albeit done in a very mature fashion. It has a steady groove. It is not unlike a lot of R&B that came before it and plenty that has come out since. It is the product of a woman who wrote some of the finest pop music of all time for others who has now turned it around on herself. Yes, there is a throughline connecting, say, "The Loco-Motion" to "It's Too Late". (And there's certainly a throughline from The Shirelles' "Will You Love Me Tomorrow" to King's "Will You Love Me Tomorrow") Her writing along with ex Gerry Goffin did a reverse Stock Aitken Waterman: they're work became less moronic as they became more accomplished and successful. Mid-to-late sixties compositions such as "Goin' Back", "Wasn't Born to Follow", "Pleasant Valley Sunday" and "The Porpoise Song" show that the pair could embrace maturity without compromising their deft pop touch.

Maturity is the big takeaway from "It's Too Late". Rather than begging or threatening or an overall sense of being pathetic, the acceptance in King's voice is a refreshing thing to hear. Obviously she didn't just come to this over night and the fact that she sounds like she has a slight cold makes it seem like she had been going through hell up until this point. Some singers are able to make it sound like they're crying but not many have been able to sound like they just stopped. A great many songs and poems have been composed during the first four stages of grief (denial, anger, bargaining, depression) but how many are left to that crucial fifth stage (acceptance)?

(I had been convinced that the line "Still I'm glad for what we had..." had been borrowed by Marvin Gaye on "When Did You Stop Loving Me, When Did I Stop Loving You" from his vindictive yet brilliant 1978 divorce album Here, My Dear only for me to discover that his line was actually "Still I remember some of the good things, baby..."; it's fascinating how reflecting on a broken down relationship can differ from the spirit of wishing a former paramour well all the way to passive-aggressive spite)

Putting aside King maturely coming to terms with the end of a relationship, "It's Too Late" is also just an outstanding single. If not quite as beguiling as Gordon Lightfoot's "If You Could Read My Mind", it is a sturdier pop song that actually reads almost as well as it sounds. If the sixties was a time when young couples rushed into marriages, then the seventies would be when many of them fell apart. Divorce and/or breakup albums would become reasonably commonplace before long. Pop and rock fans had already been fed countless songs of teen heartbreak and so now the onus was on songwriters to offer more insight as to how the love they had went so badly wrong. "It's Too Late" would become one of the foundational numbers of this burgeoning movement.

My mum had a very worn copy of Tapestry that she must've bought in the early seventies. Later, she acquired it on CD which is how I first came to hear it. Imagine my surprise, then, to discover that I already knew every single track. Perhaps she'd played the vinyl when I was young or maybe King's songs were just so damn omnipresent in the culture that I became familiar with them without even knowing it. (That said, I do have clear memories of hearing "You've Got a Friend", although that would also come via Taylor and, much later, The Housemartins) As I have already stated, it is much more musically diverse than it is normally credited. Whatsmore, "It's Too Late" (along with a handful of other tracks) gives it an erroneous reputation as a breakup album. I prefer to think of it as an account of Carole King's life as a single mother in her late twenties. After-all, it's not a Tapestry because it's about one aspect of her life but because it weaves together bits from various parts of it.

Score: 9
Unofficial Score for Tapestry: 9

~~~~~

Con Can

Growing up in the early nineties I became acquainted with "Signs" due to a (possibly?) live version of it by American hair metal band Tesla. Those poor old headbanger bands, eh? So many of them had to pull out the acoustic guitars in order to get that hit single that had eluded them for so many years. Rather than demeaning themselves with a lame love song like Extreme or Mr Big, Tesla went for a classic rock cover and respect to them. It is perhaps with this in mind that I had always assumed Ottawa's Five Man Electrical Band to be metal or proto-metal as well. In reality, they did a bit of everything that falls within the pop-rock spectrum. They won't be coming up in a review of their own but "Signs" was the first of three that came close to reaching number one on RPM and I'll be sure to cover them at least once more in this supplementary space. Though the topic of advertising being annoying and lame is hardly anything new (although maybe it was back in the seventies), 5MEB give it a good go with an easy to learn chorus and a protest song that has remained relevant ever since. It really tells you about the inefficacy of music though: if guitars did indeed "kill fascists" as Woody Guthrie believed, they've had far less luck doing away with evil corporations owning our lives. On an unrelated note, this blog is sponsored by the good people at BoredVPN: watch streaming services from around the world and we promise not to share your personal information with the AI geek who bankrolls us.

Wednesday, 11 November 2026

Ringo Starr: "It Don't Come Easy"


Album Title: Four in the Bar (or Everest)

Side One

1. Another Day — Paul McCartney
2. Instant Karma — John Lennon
3. It Don't Come Easy — Ringo Starr
4. Beware of Darkness — George Harrison
5. Imagine — John Lennon
6. Awaiting on You All — George Harrison
7. Back Seat of My Car — Paul McCartney

Side Two

1. Maybe I'm Amazed — Paul McCartney
2. Jealous Guy — John Lennon
3. What Is Life — George Harrison
4. Come and Get It — Paul McCartney
5. Give Me Some Truth (sic.) — John Lennon
6. Isn't It a Pity — George Harrison
7. Early 1970 — Ringo Starr

Oh bless you, AI. So, I will say that I appreciate that there are fourteen tracks on this fantasy Beatles album. Going all the way back to debut Please Please Me, this had been the standard for their LPs. (A Hard Day's Night and Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band have thirteen apiece but both would have had one more had dismal George Harrison contributions not been rejected) That said, this practice had gone out the window during their last couple years together. Nevertheless, John Lennon had expressed the desire to have their next (unrecorded and unreleased) album include four songs for himself, four each for McCartney and Harrison and two for Ringo "if he wants them". 

But that's the extent of my praise for this fantasy Fab Four album. First, there's the ghastly title. No one in The Beatles' orbit would have suggested Four in the Bar. I don't think anyone making a Beatles' mix tape would've come up with something so inane. It is worse than Eight Arms to Hold You, the original title for the film and soundtrack that became Help!. Plus, Everest had already been considered and abandoned as a possible name for Abbey Road and there's no way they would have gone back to it. More importantly, circumstances rule the above track listing out. Some songs on here date to 1970, others a year later and that doesn't seem to fit with The Beatles' furious workrate. And then it becomes a case of 'change one thing and everything changes with it'. Had they been in the same studio together there's a good chance that creative and competitive juices would have resulted, with whole new songs or drastic re-writes sprouting. On a related note, who's to say they would've written the same material had they still been together? McCartney's "Maybe I'm Amazed" is about his love for his wife Linda but it implicitly goes after his colleagues for not caring enough for him. Then there's "Early 1970", Ringo's open letter to Lennon, McCartney and Harrison expressing his desire to be with them again: the group had to have imploded in order for it to have been conceived of in the first place.

One track that always comes up in these imaginary thirteenth Beatles' album discussions is "It Don't Come Easy" by Ringo Starr. The drummer had started working on it in late 1968 and had it finished a year later so it would have likely been up for consideration had the Fabs kept going into 1970. Starr's trademark percussion sound and Harrison's guitar playing do provide a glimpse of what The Beatles might have done with it but the guitarist's botched Spector-ish production drags it down well below the standards of George Martin.  The sound is murky and awash in horns and backing vocalists seemingly present to keep Starr's less than powerful voice buried in the mix. Try as they might, they don't help much. If anything, Ringo sounds rougher than ever. (Except on the awful Beatles cover of Carl Perkins' "Matchbox" in which he sounds completely wasted)

With the late 1970 releases of solo album masterpieces All Things Must Pass and John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band, it must've seemed like the end of The Beatles didn't need to be mourned since they had been spun off into four potentially outstanding solo projects. (Granted, you'd either have to have had a generous perspective on the McCartney album — which I don't have — or you'd have to ignore it completely) While a big hit in a number of territories, "It Don't Come Easy" was a retort to any such optimism. Great a drummer though he no doubt was, Starr was also by far the least musically gifted. Harrison (who very likely co-wrote it even though he didn't get a songwriting credit; for what it's worth, the horn section arrangement is not unlike the George song "Savoy Truffle" from The White Album) being there was a boost but the other two are missed. If nothing else there are two takeaways: one, no wonder Ringo wrote "Early 1970" since he missed the friendship they all had and longed for his old band back; two, AI is right to put "It Don't Come Easy" on Four in the Bar since it's a song that's just crying out for the delicate touch of the most formidable band in pop.

Score: 5

Tuesday, 10 November 2026

The Rolling Stones: "Brown Sugar"


1971. Never a Dull Moment, as David Hepworth describes it. A key year with a seemingly endless list of groundbreaking, acclaimed and highly successful albums. (And absolutely none of them are overrated. Can you believe it? Me neither.) Seven of that year's number ones on the RPM charts were from some of these remarkable LPs. In that spirit, I will be adding my brief thoughts on each at the conclusion of the relevant reviews. Let's kick it off with with a big one. (Mind you, it's '71 we're talking about and they're all big — and, lest we forget, none of them are overrated)

So, I might as well be blunt: I don't care. I understand how problematic the lyrics are. There's slavery, there's torture, there's rape, there's...uh, interracial sex (proof that not everything about "Brown Sugar" has aged poorly). It doesn't look good. Mick Jagger admitted back in the nineties that he'd never write it now. The Rolling Stones tried altering the lyrics so as to soften just how disgusting it is but they eventually gave up and stopped performing it live. To their credit, they never cried about being "censored" or how they had become victims of the long arm of the politically correct thought police. The time had simply come to retire it from setlists. Fair enough. I just don't care.

"Brown Sugar" was not the first time the Stones acted like despicable pukes. "Satisfaction" is about self pleasure. At least two tracks from my beloved Aftermath album are about misogyny (though "Stupid Girl" can at least claim to be about one particular female, "Under My Thumb" has no similar case for plausible deniability). Dependable old Charlie Watts aside, everyone else had been arrested for various lewd acts — and it's not as if they entered the seventies vowing to change their ways. If anything, the breakup of The Beatles a year earlier may have freed up The Rolling Stones to act like bigger pigs than they already were. Having long been in the shadow of the Fab Four (to the extent that Paul McCartney playing an acetate of the recently recorded single "Hey Jude" overshadowed the band premiering their own new album Beggars Banquet at a party that had been thrown in the Stones' honour; the following year they titled their follow-up LP Let It Bleed almost as an acknowledgement that they were doomed to be stuck in the shadow of The Beatles — or at least until they broke up six months later), they could do what they wanted and claim without hesitation that they were indeed the Greatest Rock 'n' Roll Group in the World.

"Brown Sugar" was their first major single of the seventies but it dated back to the end of 1969. The Stones entered the famed Muscle Shoals studio in Alabama for a very brief period of recording and they made the most of it. They cut the bluesy "You Gotta Move", the sensitive "Wild Horses" and this searing rock classic. It could have made for an EP for the ages but contract issues with the notorious Allan Klein got them to hold it over for eighteen months. (They didn't have enough time at Muscle Shoals to make a whole album as they were due to perform at Altamont just two days later; they played a rough "Brown Sugar" there for the very first time to an indifferent response) This was the first sign that the Stones of the seventies were going to be a entirely different beast from what they had been in the swinging sixties. Rather than working to the demands of their management and/or record label, they were now going to record at their own pace. (Let It Bleed had been their eighth album in just five years; during the course of the seventies they put out a total of only five LPs) Indeed, "Brown Sugar" sets them up for much of what was to come: the dirty rock sound of their 1972 tour-de-force Exile on Main Street, a greater reliance on bigger and bigger riffs to the point in which 1981's "Start Me Up" verged on self-parody and lyrics that began to turn away from current issues and more towards the carnal desires of Mick Jagger.

It's a little odd to think that this was the same Jagger who only a few months' earlier had been penning anthems of the revolutionary left that rivaled John Lennon's. "Street Fighting Man" and "Gimme Shelter" are so effective that suddenly hearing about "Gold Coast slaves" and "house boys" would cause consternation, especially in the twenty-first century. Perhaps Lennon represents an interesting parallel. While simultaneously going through primal scream therapy, the erstwhile Beatle was still dabbling in Maoist street chants of varying quality. "Power to the People" had been a Top 5 hit on the RPM hit parade and it included the famous line "I ask you comrade and brother, how do you treat the woman back home?". Lennon noticed old fashioned male chauvinism in the left which he was keen (and right) to address. A year later, however, he was comparing the plight of women to that of blacks, even suggesting that they had it worse and using the N word just to hammer the point home. With this in mind, is it really that much of a stretch that Jagger practically celebrates violence against slaves in the American South the same way he eulogizes the Salt of the Earth? If nothing else it goes to show you how being on the political left doesn't necessarily make you a true blue progressive. (And this is even before we get into just how genuinely political Jagger and Lennon were in the first place)

Still, I already said that I don't care so the above shouldn't matter to me anyway. What matters is the song itself and what a song it is. Having long been an advocate for the Brian Jones era I must admit that he isn't missed here. (In fact, it's impossible to imagine the great multi-instrumentalist adding anything to it either) Replacement Mick Taylor, who had been almost as little used on Let It Bleed as the soon-to-be-relieved-of-his-duties Jones, plays a lovely blues counterpoint to Keith Richards' forceful rhythm part, an elegance within the rough. Watts and bassist Bill Wyman prove that they were the finest rhythm section after Donald "Duck" Dunn and Al "The Human Metronome" Jackson of Booker T and the MG's. Fired for not looking the part but still a cog in their inner circle, Ian Stewart makes a strong case for why his Rolling Stone membership should never have been revoked. Finally, there's Jagger. His vocal is as charismatic as his already unmatched stage presence. As if aware of the potential firestorm in his lyrics, he wisely went for an even more garbled than normal enunciation ("I bet your mama was a Cheshire queen..."). And while fans may worship Richards for living by the rock 'n' roll sword — presumably, he'll die from it one day as well — note that it was Jagger himself who wrote virtually all of "Brown Sugar": problematic lyrics and astonishing music, all from one man who isn't given much credit for either of those things.

"Brown Sugar" is really the zenith of the Stones. It has all those qualities mentioned above plus it has everything their other hits are supposed to have. The groove never quits, the intensity keeps building and you can even dance to it if the mood hits. (Of course, when it comes to mood, I am always up for giving it a listen) "Satisfaction" may be the important one that everyone took notice of and "Paint It Black" is their brooding dark side at its finest. "I Am Waiting" is poignant and "Street Fighting Man" is their great anthem. All terrific songs, all basically just also rans compared to the best single they ever cut in all its complex, disgusting glory.

"Brown Sugar" opens Sticky Fingers but it's a testament to the creative roll the Stones were on that its remaining nine tracks very nearly keep pace. It's a nice pot pourri selection of everything they were capable of. "Wild Horses" is such a great country-rock number that The Flying Burrito Brothers (along with among many, many others in the years ahead) promptly did their own superlative version. It is contrasted (or complemented) by the more jokey "Dead Flowers". "Bitch" opens side two and is like "Brown Sugar"'s poor cousin. And "Moonlight Mile" is such a brilliant album closer that Richards decided to leave it untouched after he slept in and missed most of a session. The crown jewel of the Stones' so-called big four. (Did I happen to mention that Aftermath is my favourite album of theirs?)

Score: 10
Unofficial Score for Sticky Fingers: 10

Friday, 6 November 2026

Three Dog Night: "Joy to the World"


One of the great pop injustices occurred on Billboard's Hot 100 on the week of April 24, 1971. Three Dog Night's "Joy to the World" leapfrogged Marvin Gaye's "What's Going On" into the number one spot thus denying an all-timer's rightful spot in favour of an irritatingly catchy pop hit. (What makes this worse is that 3DN had already passed their short-lived creative peak) Up in Canada, things didn't pan out quite the same. Yes, "Joy to the World" also hit the top spot - and stayed there for an improbable six weeks, matching its stay on top of the American charts — but Marvelous Marvin was not in the runner up position. No, he was all the way down at number seventy-eight, two spots below its peak position from a week earlier.

Resentment towards Three Do Night may have existed down south but no one blamed them for preventing one of pop's greatest songs from hitting the top of the RPM hit parade. Gaye did remarkably well with the best album he ever cut, its title track and two more Top 10 hits ("Mercy, Mercy Me" and "Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)" in the United States but his impact on the rest of the world was minimal. A fear of flying and Motown's poor track record of promoting their acts internationally meant that their biggest star had a ceiling. (Ironically, Gaye would later relocate to Belgium and perform a handful of concerts to appreciative audiences around Europe)

Three Dog Night were in the midst of a run of thirteen consecutive Top 10 hits in Canada when "Joy to the World" hit the top. "Easy to Be Hard" and "Mama Told Me Not to Come" only just missed the number one spot and both "One" and "Eli's Coming" weren't far behind. All are vastly better than this one. While a bunch of dudes recording a Laura Nyro composition all about avoiding a sexual predator might seem like a misstep, "Eli's Coming" was likely their finest moment. Granted, her original is that much better (being one of many high spots on her glorious second album Eli and the Thirteenth Confession) but they are to be commended simply for not messing it up. It was during the late sixties that 3DN relied on some of pop's finest songwriters for their material. In addition to Nyro, they recorded songs by Randy Newman, Harry Nilsson and the still largely unknown duo of Elton John and Bernie Taupin. (They also covered lesser known songs by well known acts, including the Lennon-McCartney track "It's for You" which had initially been done by Cilla Black) Yet, by the time they got to fourth album Naturally, however, the songwriting quality had been scaled down from 'first-rate' to merely 'respectable'.

Hoyt Axton was born into songwriting. His mother Mae Boren co-wrote Elvis Presley's "Heartbreak Hotel" in 1954 (and would, surprisingly, discover future pop star Tiffany some thirty years later). While she never could replicate its success, she was respected in Nashville at a time when men dominated everything (as, indeed, they still do). Like his mother, Hoyt struggled to make a name for himself at first and seemed to do better as a character actor on TV. He had a workable melody for a new song but had to make lyrics up on the spot. Some members of 3DN weren't crazy about it but it was felt that something silly and childish might be just the thing they needed. The public certainly agreed.

"Joy to the World" doesn't seem bad at first. The soulful cry of "Jeremiah was a bullfrog..." certainly makes for a memorable opening but not a whole lot happens from that point on. I don't think there's anything wrong with having a song that might appeal to children but I don't think the members of 3DN had many ideas as to going about doing so. Having playful, nonsense verse is a start but the only novel element in the recording was the decision to have all seven members of the group singing together instead of the standard trio of Danny Hutton, Chuck Negron and Cory Wells. This ought to lend it a singalong charm not unlike The Beatles' "Yellow Submarine" but it lacks a folksy Ringo to guide it.

Even still, it needn't be as bad as it is. Thinking about it right now, I feel as though I ought to like it more than I do. Unfortunately, it's irritating. And repetitive. And it's an example of contrived cheeriness in pop music that only makes me want to put on some Cure so I might not be in such a bad mood. Worst of all, it is a perfect example of vocal excess. They might as well be doing a commercial jingle for insurance for all of their misplaced passion. They were willing to try out a silly song but they couldn't bring themselves to become a silly band and only managed to come out of it looking sillier than ever.

Score: 3

Thursday, 5 November 2026

The Bells: "Stay Awhile"


Soft, kind of creepy, bad mustaches. Yes, The Bells had a great deal to answer for. I, however, would rather not be so negative and I'd prefer to focus on the good qualities present in their signature hit: delicate, unsettling (i.e. 'creepy but in kind of a good way'), sensual. "Stay Awhile" can be off putting but it has grown on me. While I wouldn't necessarily go out of my way to put it on, I wouldn't rush to turn it off either.

In researching this review, I discovered that its cover versions are surprisingly few and far between — and those that do exist are by a bunch of people I've mostly never heard of. Fellow Canadian Ken Tobias, who actually wrote "Stay Awhile", did it in a light country style not unlike John Denver. It's interesting but surprisingly free of horniness and it becomes clear that the decision on the part of The Bells to do it as a duet was a wise one. Yet, not many subsequent duos have taken it on. Let's look at a few who might have done well with it:

The Beautiful South
Big in their native Britain but just a cult act at best in Canada (and they only managed to do even that well because support from Good Rockin' Tonite, Video Hits and MuchMusic playing their promos for "Song for Whoever" and "A Little Time"), the sextet with three vocalists would have been perfect for "Stay Awhile". Original female singer Brianna Corrigan had the helium-voiced tone to match Jacki Ralph's seductive reading and she always paired well with the passive-aggressive sneer of Dave Hemingway. Alternatively, leader Paul Heaton and Corrigan's replacement Jacqui Abbott could have done a tension-packed, smokey duet. It would have no doubt been nothing more than a B side though.

Nick Cave and Saint Etienne
One of those unlikely nineties' team-ups (something that both acts had prior experience doing) sees the Australian goth legend Cave really bring out the dark heart in "Stay Awhile" while Sarah Cracknell would have smouldered ironically alongside him. Plus, something tells me that lifelong pop obsessives Bob Stanley and Pete Wiggs were fond of The Bells and would've loved nothing more than to add some loungy synths for that extra bit of sparkle. A fantasy pop winner!

UB40 and Chrissie Hynde
They did an awful cover of Sonny and Cher's "I Got You Babe" but then later put out a reasonably good version of Dusty Springfield's "Breakfast in Bed" and it's possible that they could've been looking for a third potential classic to revisit. Pretenders' singer Hynde could have thrived with it but I'm less certain when it comes to Ali Campbell's phlegmy whine. Also, cod reggae "Stay Awhile"? Just because I'd like to hear it doesn't mean I'd enjoy it. On the other hand, anything would've been better than UB40 and Robert Palmer's horrible version of Bob Dylan's "I'll Be Your Baby Tonight".

One of those late eighties' cross-generational duets
Following Bryan Adams and Tina Turner's "It's Only Love", Aretha Franklin and George Michael's "I Knew You Were Waiting for Me", Pet Shop Boys and Dusty Springfield's "What Have I Done to Deserve This?" and Buck Owens and Dwight Yoakam's "Streets of Bakersfield", "Stay Awhile" by a contemporary pop act their peak along with a faded star from the sixties would have had the markings of a hit single. What about Ann Wilson of Heart and, say, Del Shannon? Or Lulu and Johnny Hates Jazz? Petula Clark and Jimmy Sommerville of The Communards? Okay, now you're just being silly.

A random 90s R&B pairing
As I will no doubt explore further, the contrast between male R&B acts (deeply serious, robotically romantic, all sporting glasses whether they needed 'em or not) and their female counterparts (cheerful yet sassy, actually seemed to enjoy being pop stars, didn't act as if they were carrying the weight of the world on their backs) was stark. While having differing perspectives doesn't always work on a pop duet, it actually might have suited a song like "Stay Awhile". He — Babyface, for example — could be your average soul Romeo and she — I could see Shanice in the role — could be flirtatious and coy. The Nice Cave/Saint Etienne collaboration aside, I think this one would have had the most potential.

Someone Canadian (or Canadian-adjacent)
This is a blog about the Canadian charts and I'm a Canadian so why the hell not? But who exactly do I picture stepping up with a fresh version of "Stay Awhile" c. 2003? Neko Case and Rufus Wainwright seems like a good match. Or maybe Feist and The Unicorns? They could've performed it at the Juno Awards as they honoured The Bells with a Lifetime Achievement award. Or, more realistically, a You're Lucky Anyone Still Remembers You award.

Like it or not, The Bells hit a mark on "Stay Awhile" that not just anyone could have or would have been able to replicate. Some of the examples above seem like cool ideas but it's probably for the best that they remain that way. While we may expect to catch lightning in a bottle with an all-time great pop hit, sometimes similar things can be achieved with much less to work with. Pop music may not have needed The Bells but I'm happy they had their time nonetheless.

Score: 6

Wednesday, 4 November 2026

Tom Jones: "She's a Lady"


It was 1957. The first Canadian singles chart was published to very little fanfare. At the top of this maiden hit parade stood, fittingly enough, Elvis Presley with "All Shook Up", a rock 'n' roll number that kept the momentum of his extraordinary 1956 rolling along. It also happened to be a chart topper in many other countries around the world. Though still at an early stage of The King's career, it must have almost seemed old hat at the time. Another great Elvis song, what else is new?

Future members of The Beatles were, naturally, in awe of Elvis's singing, the sound his band created and the way he looked - and they weren't the only ones. In Ottawa, a teenage singer-songwriter named Paul Anka was similarly impressed. So, too, was a newlywed singer from Wales born Thomas Woodward. But while John Lennon and Paul McCartney kept performing rock 'n' roll — first to some very small and disinterested crowds in their native Liverpool, later to more enthusiastic audiences in Hamburg and, finally, to thousands of screaming girls around the world — Anka and the soon-to-be-rebranded Tom Jones operated almost as if Elvis had never existed at all. They seemed more in the tradition of jazz singers like Bing Crosby and Frank Sinatra. It was only after Elvis returned from his stint in the US armed forces that the three began to have careers that dovetailed in style — and that was only because The King became more like them.

Fortunately, Elvis wasn't going to remain stale forever. (Even though he would sadly revert back to form before long) By the end of the sixties he had revived his fortunes with his celebrated Comeback Special, the remarkable album From Elvis in Memphis and the equally brilliant single "Suspicious Minds". Not only had he rediscovered rock but he had also begun to once again embrace country, gospel and R&B. Meanwhile, Jones' chart success and magnetic personality enabled him to host a television variety show of his own, titled This Is Tom Jones beginning in 1969. Musical guests came from both sides of the pond and beyond and weren't confined to the emerging Las Vegas residency clubs that Jones was becoming a fixture on. One of his guests on the December 4, 1969 episode was Janis Joplin of all people. Not one to hide from a challenge, Jones joined her on "Raise Your Hand" — along with his crack house band — and the two were on fire in vocalists' materclass.

So, there's some context to a single like "She's a Lady". But the most important thing is that Jones finally came to realize that rock 'n' roll raunch suited his sexed up fever dream. Even Anka, the song's composer, seemed to have this in mind in his own recording, though he has never had the vocal prowess of the Welsh Tiger. A horn section, a bit of strings and a set of backing vocalists are present and correct but it's the rhythm section that I'm here for. With a greater intensity to the arrangement, Jones ups his game with a grittier performance than what he typically gives. He doesn't sound like he's playing to an audience or that he's sending himself up (qualities that no doubt make him a peerless concert attraction to this day), he just sounds urgently in need of a shag. This being Tom Jones, I'm fully bought into it.

"She's a Lady" is a pleasant surprise following the silly "What's New Pussycat?" and the ghastly "Without You" but this is where the Tom Jones story comes to an end as far as this blog goes. Way to go out on a high note. I don't imagine I'll ever be much of a fan but this does make me interested in investigating this era of his career. (Follow-up single "Puppet Man", which would end up being his final Top 10 hit in Canada, is also strong so I really must give the She's a Lady album a listen) And maybe I should even try to see him if I get the opportunity. I just hope he still has some of that raunchy rock in him.

Score: 7

~~~~~

Can Con

Not the highest placing domestic hit this particular week — stay tuned for them — but Calgary's own Stampeders round out the Top 5 with "Carry Me". It's a pleasant little tune with a chorus that's easy to sing along with but I'm a little surprised it managed to go all the way to number two. there's a little more country from them than I'd like but, then again, their best known song opens with a banjo solo so what the hell do I know? A little underwhelming but maybe I'm just kind of turned off by the very un-Canadian narrative of a disabled war vet wanting to get back to Birmingham, Alabama and his Sarah-Ann. I would've preferred a story of a draft dodger or deserter taking off with his girl up to Canada so they can start a new life together in a country that didn't wish nothing but pain and suffering from them. A lot of Americans were fleeing north of the border at the time and it would've been nice to have heard that immortalized in a song. Oh well. The Stampeders will be back in this space before long with a banjo to play them in. I can't wait.

Tuesday, 3 November 2026

The Partridge Family: "Doesn't Somebody Want to Be Wanted"


0:29: Oh come on David, it's not that bad! I mean, the song is nothing special at this early stage but there's nowhere to go but up and your vocal is quite strong. You sound committed. You're like the Bret Hart of bubblegum pop: among all this phoniness, you're there to bring it back to reality. A tip of the hat to you, sir!

1:21: Wait, is this a country song in disguise? "Doesn't Somebody Want to Be Wanted" is just The Partridge Family's second single and they're already going for the more conservative audience? What about all their teen fans who lusted after David and/or Susan? Or the very sad eight-year-old boys who looked up to Danny as a roll model? I'm not even fully convinced that this was done to appease Shirley. She couldn't have wanted this for her ambitious stepson David, could she?

1:34: I can't say I'm fond of the syntax used in "Doesn't Somebody Want to Be Wanted". Wouldn't 'anybody' or 'anyone' be preferable? Having possibly alienated them with their shift, perhaps the awkward title is a gesture to the girls (and, I dare say, a few boys) who had feelings for David. "He's lonely and he'll settle for anyone!" coos Audrey, 15, of North Bay, Ontario.

1:47: Oh good lord, David's talking??? Even in genuinely thrilling pop like Pulp's "Common People" spoken word bits ought to be avoided but in the case of a tune that I'm already considering turning off well before it's over, this is an especially ill advised move. He sounds like a televangelist pleading with his followers to send him more seed money. He wasn't crazy about this song to begin with but this was where David almost put his foot down. I suppose he didn't want to make this kind of power move at such an early stage in his career but it's important to stand up for yourself. I don't do it myself but I've been reliably informed that it works at least some of the time.

2:20: The Monkees may not have played on all their singles but at least they looked like they might have liked them. There's no way that even young tykes Jeremy (later Brian) or Suzanne (not to be confused with Susan, not that I would have) would have been into this. And speaking of the least useful members of The Partridge Family (and, yes, that includes Simone the dog), they weren't even pretending that the two brats were playing on their recordings, were they? Still, I'm sure everyone from the TV series had better things to do — as, indeed, do I.

Score: 2

Creedence Clearwater Revival: "Have You Ever Seen the Rain?"


There are two commonplace theories as to the meaning of "Have You Ever Seen the Rain?". The first is that it tracks the early seventies fall out of disillusioned hippies and radicals following the tragedies at the Altamont Festival at the end of 1969 and the shootings at Kent State the following year. While this smacks of an after-the-fact analysis (and isn't it a good thing I've never stooped to such a level), it should be said that Beach Boy Mike Love was thinking along similar lines at roughly the same time with his divisive number "Student Demonstration Time", from their groundbreaking 1971 album Surf's Up. While seemingly siding with protesters, Love's song concludes with a warning of "you best stay outta sight" which seemed to reflect the hippie-to-yuppie changeover that would occur.

To the extent that it even has anything in common with "Student Demonstration Time", "Have You Ever Seen the Rain?" is much more ambiguous. Is the rain supposed to represent the diminished commitment of these young anti-war, pro-civil rights individuals? I guess it could be but then wouldn't the sun symbolize their renewed desire to keep at it? It can rain on a sunny day so there's a mix of good and bad? Right?

Though very much of their time, I'm not convinced that Creedence Clearwater Revival were ever all that political. I know "Bad Moon Rising" is meant to have a deeper meaning and all that but I think that's mainly down to reverse engineering a memorable hit to fit in with such a polarized time. I imagine John Fogerty would have written it independent of the political situation in the United States. And the same goes for "Have You Ever Seen the Rain?".

The other theory is one that Fogerty has pushed for himself — and, for all I know, he may have been the first person to even broach it. Instead of it being about Vietnam, it was about a coming disaster that was much closer to home. CCR had been living on borrowed time for a while by the start of 1971. Fogerty's older brother and bandmate Tom was unhappy with his role in the group and he decided to leave following completion of their sixth album Pendulum. Lines like "there's a calm before the storm" and "been that way for all my time" would seem to confirm this. I'm happy to take his word for it but, again, there's an uncertainty. Shouldn't the sun hint at the possibility of a bright future for the band in spite of their difficulties? Or is it simply a stark contrast between the rain being his crumbling group and the sun being his future without them?

Something else seems to be going on in "Have You Ever Seen the Rain?" that suggests the end is near. Fogerty sounds like he's ready to give up. There are precisely two verses, the chorus repeats and that's about it. No bridge and not much of a narrative to go by. (The competing theories mentioned above could've both done with greater lyrical explanation) Fogerty also sounds exhausted and who the hell could've blamed him given his workrate over the previous three years. While previous RPM number ones "Up Around the Bend" and "Lookin' Out My Backdoor" have issue of their own, both feel toiled over and completed. Now, a torpor has begun — and it would only get worse from here. Luckily, the coming sunshine in this thunderstorm of CCR's decline is the fact that we're just about done with them.

Score: 4

Sunday, 1 November 2026

The Osmonds: "One Bad Apple"


There was a time when ABBA were considered to be the ultimate in seventies' Eurotrash tackiness. The Carpenters were regarded as soft and bloodless — and, worst of all, they were so establishment that they went to the White House to meet Richard Nixon (though so did Duke Ellington). The Monkees were seen as manufactured pop inanity. The Archies were disliked so much that they didn't even factor as snobby music critics' whipping boys. Yet, the influence of Rolling Stone magazine could only go so far. To one extent or another, all four have been accorded much more favourable critical re-evaluations since roughly the nineties.

Which leaves...well, plenty of other pop acts hoping for a boost to their legacies. Late eighties'/early nineties' teen pop sensations Bros (mostly a UK concern; their name rhymes with 'floss' rather than 'rose') and New Kids on the Block have so far not been favourably re-appraised, even though they had a significant impact on the likes of Take That, Westlife, Backstreet Boys and NSYNC. The same goes for Paul Anka, Frankie Avalon and even Cliff Richard, even though they were all instrumental in keeping the pop industry afloat during the pre-Beatles' interregnum of the early sixties. The leading bubblegum groups like Paul Revere and the Raiders and 1910 Fruitgum Company have mostly been left out, proving that the poptimists would rather re-consider the merits of fake groups rather than real ones.

The Osmonds are yet another bright and shiny pop act who were looked down upon by critics at the time and who are still waiting for second chance to make a first impression. They may have to wait a while longer. "One Bad Apple" is likely the best they'd ever do and that's only because they were doing an unabashed Jackson 5 ripoff. Perhaps not wishing to hammer the whitewashing home, they proceeded to record a series of bland, middle-of-the-road numbers that perfectly suited such a bland, middle-of-the-road group of brothers. Unfortunately, they aren't very good but that's — sadly — for future reviews of the Ogden, Utah family act.

In any case, it's clear even from their one passable pop hit why the re-evaluations haven't been forthcoming. Thieving from the Jacksons would be bad enough but they don't even do it very well. Donny Osmond was ahead of his time in one regard: he would be the first of many to try (and fail) at capturing Michael Jackson's lightning in a bottle. He was two years Michael's senior so maybe it was puberty but whatever it was, he simply didn't have the range. The playing is a little clunky too. Then, there's the other Osmonds: Alan, Wayne, the other one, the other other one. Try as they might to sound like Tito, Jackie, Jermaine and Marlon (See? I only had to double check their names, not look them up half-a-dozen times only to keep forgetting them all), they just end up sounding more like members of the barbershop quartet they had always been. Even the song itself it third rate compared to gems like "I Want You Back" and "ABC": I guess if you're going to copy someone badly you might as well go all in with it.

ABBA, The Carpenters, The Monkees and even the bloody Archies all had pop craft backing them up. You could dismiss how they looked, how they were presented, what they stood for and even what was at the heart of their material but there was no denying that there was genuine human talent involved, whether on stage or behind the scenes. The same can't be said for The Osmonds. While nowhere near as deplorable as someone like Pat Boone, they were his seventies' equivalent. (That is until we get to Debby Boone) Credit to them for not being horrible which just about the best that can be said. So, yeah, the critical re-appraisal is not happening. As for Bros and New Kids, you never know...

Score: 4

Saturday, 31 October 2026

Gordon Lightfoot: "If You Could Read My Mind"


It didn't exactly wow critics and fans to begin with but John Lennon's Plastic Ono Band album played the long game: over time, its influence has been felt. The rise of breakup/divorce albums over the course of the seventies and beyond — Bob Dylan's Blood on the Tracks, Fleetwood Mac's Rumours, Bruce Springsteen's Tunnel of Love just to name the most obvious examples — owes more than a little to Lennon's raw nerve lyrics. Then, there's the role it played on barebones, lo-fi releases from Nick Drake's Pink Moon to the largely unlistenable yet still compelling demos of the sick and tortured Daniel Johnston.

Lennon's solo debut isn't often lumped in with the burgeoning singer-songwriter movement of the early seventies. Though not dissimilar, they floated independently of one another. Lennon's openness contrasted with a group of individuals who struggled to express their feelings so directly. Relationships collapsed around them but they were unable or unwilling to dive deep into what caused their breakups. This must read like a criticism but it shouldn't be taken as one. Couples drift apart all the time but the how and/or the why can sometimes be virtually impossible to answer. Lennon was all for getting the truth out there — even if he could still be prone to mythologizing the life he and Yoko Ono had together — but this could be easier said than done when it came to even some of the more accomplished coffeehouse folk singers of the era.

A look at the above photo from the Italian release of "If You Can Read My Mind" (which is nearly identical to the cover of the album Sit Down Young Stranger from the previous year) shows Gordon Lightfoot looking out the window, his appearance tight lipped, concerned but not giving away too much. He looks caught between being a rugged man's man who keeps his issues to himself (and, perhaps, a trusty bottle of vodka) and a more modern day guy who's open with his feelings. In order to keep with the times he is keen to share his inner thoughts but his instinct is to be guarded. Having a song called "If You Could Read My Mind" is practically daring his audience to give it a try.

I first heard "If You Could Read My Mind" while in my late teens. Being used to Neil Tennant's sophisticated wit, Morrissey's outsider meditations, Michael Stipe's irresistible nonsense and Billy Bragg's charmed agitprop, I thought it was absolute dreck. Sure, Lightfoot could sing pretty well and I could even see why people found it so moving but I couldn't get past the old time movies and paperback novels from the drugstore and all that crap. While I would gradually grow to appreciate the song on the whole, these references were remained cringey. Who sings this stuff? And who would write it? Who would even think such shit? Turns out, I do.

I think there are a couple ways of looking at the lyrical quirks in Lightfoot's first RPM number one. First, he's stalling. Rather than being unaware of what divides him and his ex, he actually knows whats up but can't face dealing with it so he invents these roadblocks of ghosts and fallen heroes. He even recognizes what he's up to when he chimes in with the line "but for now love, let's be real". Excuse me, but aren't you the one coming up with all this fanciful stuff in order to avoid having to face up to your responsibilities and you're telling someone else to "be real"?

The other thing going on is a kind of subconscious bullshit. I have looked back on the ruins of failed relationships and thrown out theories as to what went wrong without careful consideration of facts or logic. (If you're going to be a conspiracy theorist make all the crap you conjure up about yourself rather than the outside world) Lightfoot is referencing crummy B movies and crappy romance novels the same way I might quote from Seinfeld or The Simpsons — and he's gone and applied them to his own situation. I don't what these similes are supposed to mean and I'm not sure anyone is — I'm not even convinced that Lightfoot himself could have told you (not that he would have).

Again, this surely reads as if I'm bashing the song and Lightfoot in general but nothing could be further from the truth. I like the fact that he keeps avoiding the topic because that's what I do. We already had Lennon and Dylan and Leonard Cohen to provide mental images that we'd never imagined before, what Lightfoot did better than anyone else was putting into words thoughts that everyone has had before but never sang or wrote about. Some of us can't deal with confrontation and want nothing more than to hide away from it. Other forms of media will lecture me that I should "stand up for myself" but I shouldn't have to. We the meek and mild need a voice of our own. Some will no doubt opt for Jesus but old Gord is saviour enough for me.

"I never thought I could act this way..."

Lightfoot has detoured enough and at last he can get to the point — but only up to a point. He still doesn't know what happened and won't let on what he did wrong. (A second pass at this sort of chorus has him admitting that he "never thought he could feel this way" but I prefer how it comes out the first time; at least there's an attempt at accounting for his actions even if, as ever, he declines to go into detail) A bluntness hangs in the air with the resigned "...but the feeling's gone and I just can't get it back": we've all been there.

Gordon Lightfoot will be back in this blog before long. His remaining RPM chart toppers are both great in their own right with many fans and members of the wider Baby Boom generation preferring one or both of them to this single. (His trio of Canadian number ones is made up of the three songs he remains arguably best remembered for which is a surprisingly rare feat) While I can understand the differing views, I can't possibly agree. "If You Could Read My Mind" not only survives what is on the surface some shaky lyrics but it has also withstood a seemingly endless parade of well-meaning cover versions — and none of them are even all that bad. Yet, topping Lightfoot's skill move of saying so much, expressing so little and still creating an emotional steam engine was always going to be a tough act for him — or anyone else — to follow.

Score: 10

Wednesday, 28 October 2026

Lynn Anderson: "Rose Garden"


During the year I spent in Britain in the late eighties, my family and I seemed to take our homesickness out on the culture at large. We'd get irritated by constant references to America and, by extension, no one knowing anything about Canada. We naively assumed that our far deeper connection to the old Empire would have endeared us to the locals but it meant nothing to them. Thus, we'd cling to even the most modest of acknowledgments. (Except, of course, when it came to the Ben Johnson steroid scandal at the Seoul Olympics) The slightest mention of our homeland on TV would get us excited. If we happened to drive by a large hotel we'd be sure to check to see if a Canadian flag was flying alongside the American, Australian, French and German standards — and we'd all be indignant when it wasn't in its rightful place (which it never was).

It was a pleasant surprise, then, when "I Beg Your Pardon" by Toronto's Kon Kan started climbing the UK Top 40.in the spring of 1989. It mattered little that they sounded like the most British synth-pop group imaginable (Graeme Kay in Smash Hits was unimpressed by their unoriginal sound, describing them as a "cross between New Order and Depeche Mode"): they were from Canada and so were we and that was all that mattered! While my hope that "I Beg Your Pardon" might go all the way to the top was wishful thinking, its eventual peak at number five was an achievement nonetheless.

The clearly sampled bit — you know, as opposed to a good deal of the rest of the song whose many sampled bits weren't quite as easy to spot — was from "Rose Garden", a song that I had long assumed to be by fellow Canadian k.d. lang. (Actually, I wasn't entirely wrong on that one because the performance artist turned torch singer did record it a couple years prior to Kon Kan's use of it) I had no idea who Lynn Anderson was and it wasn't as if the success of "I Beg Your Pardon" brought her back into the public eye. In fact, "project" leader Barry Harris didn't go out of his way to acknowledge her, claiming at the time to have written it "in a Lisbon subway". It was only later that he admitted that he wanted to do with "Rose Garden" what the Pet Shop Boys had done with the Elvis Presley/Willie Nelson standard "Always on My Mind": take a popular country anthem and transform it into a slice of glorious pop. (He failed to do so but writing a whole new pop song around another is not just something any old fart can do so we'll let it slide)

Lynn Anderson had been a country star since the mid-sixties with a handful of hits on the American and Canadian country charts to her credit, including the number one smash "Big Girls Don't Cry", which had nothing to do with The Four Seasons song of the same name. She also began to make a name for herself on The Lawrence Welk Show, which, much to my surprise, wasn't the name of a mind-numbingly boring political panel show on American public broadcasting. (I'm sorry but the name Lawrence Welk says 'candid, off-the-cuff, hard hitting analysis', not 'all-around family entertainer') Like Welk, Anderson hailed from North Dakota but this meant she was an outsider when it came to being accepted by Nashville's country establishment. Rather than looking to the emerging Bakersfield sound like Buck Owens and Merle Haggard (a scene that frankly could've used a female lead singer) or leaning towards mainstream pop, she doubled down on her pursuit of being accepted by Music City. (Considering the lengthy career she subsequently enjoyed and the fact that she died in Nashville, it would seem she succeeded) And in doing so she had her one and only pop hit.

"Rose Garden" was written in 1967 by Joe South who also took a stab at recording it. There's nothing really wrong with his original but it does sound like he had Elvis Presley in mind while singing it. For whatever reason the King never tried it out himself but star Billy Joe Royal did put out a version of his own. Again, his take on it is all right though a little too jokey and cornball for my taste. Playing up the comedy aspect of "Rose Garden" is a legitimate choice and it is one that Anderson makes herself albeit with more subtlety. Her reading is not unlike a serious dramatic actor playing a comedy role as straight as possible who then still gets the required laughs. It helps as well that it's delivered from a female perspective: Anderson lends a touch of wisdom that simply isn't there in either the South or Royal versions.

Which brings us back round to "I Beg Your Pardon": it's almost a duet. Yeah, I know that Anderson's sample ("Smile for a while and let's be jolly...") is only brief but her part provides an effective counterpoint to singer Kevin Wynne's angst, a suggestion to "Cheer Up!" that doesn't come across as patronizing. The country singer would reflect on the huge success of "Rose Garden" and comment that it fitted the times when the United States was divided and coming out of the Vietnam years and needed some light relief. There's probably something to this and it works just as well in a spot of synth doom and gloom. So, props to Lynn Anderson: she took an ordinary country-pop song and made everyone take notice and then her vocal was used on a modern synth-pop hit and did the same the thing. Ignore all her country hits and she could even qualify to be a double one-hit wonder.

Score: 7 (which is precisely the same score I'd be giving to "I Beg Your Pardon" only it peaked at a measly number nineteen in Canada; there aren't many Canadians who can claim to be more popular in Britain than they are back home. It's basically them and former Prime Minister R.B. Bennett, the man who did as little as possible for his people during the Great Depression)

Sunday, 25 October 2026

Bee Gees: "Lonely Days"


It was on Boxing Day, 1967 that the British public received a shock to the system: they discovered that The Beatles weren't infallible. Their hour-long feature film Magical Mystery Tour baffled millions of viewers with its surrealism and lack of plot. The group's plan was to board a bus with a collection of actors, friends, musicians and circus performers and film whatever happened along the way. "Unfortunately", as Malcolm McDowell in the classic eighties' documentary The Compleat Beatles put it, "nothing did".

Magical Mystery Tour was considered to be The Beatles' folly. The BBC, who showed it, faced minimal, if any, backlash. It was perhaps with this in mind that they agreed to broadcast yet another oddball film also starring a pop group, the Bee Gees' Cucumber Castle on the day after Christmas, 1970. Though a clear (if very flimsy) storyline is present, it may well be worse than Magical Mystery Tour. The Beatles had some decent music to keep them afloat while the brothers Gibb were floundering creatively. Whatsmore, their numbers were reduced with Robin having left the group following the fallout caused by Odessa, their one true album masterpiece. Whether a trio or a duo, the Bee Gees weren't John Lennon or Ringo Starr when it came to screen presence. They weren't even Paul McCartney. At best they were a band of George Harrisons which was problematic since one was more than enough. (Charismatic actress Eleanor Bron was part of a talented but underutilized Cucumber Castle cast; she had previously been in The Beatles' pointless and silly 1965 film Help!, another deeply flawed picture that is nevertheless superior to the Bee Gees' debut motion picture)

The funny thing is, Cucumber Castle didn't harm their reputation all that much. Their popularity had already begun to wane in the UK (despite recent number two hits for both the Barry-Maurice incarnation — "Don't Forget to Remember" — and for Robin's solo career — "Saved by the Bell") while their stock in North America as reliable soft rock hitmakers remained largely unchanged. While the BBC's flagship channel put Magical Mystery Tour on the air, it was left to poor cousin BBC2 to deal with the Bee Gees' cinematic endeavour. Being a ratings bonanza, The Beatles ended up embarrassing themselves in front of more or less an entire nation; on the other hand, since few bothered tuning into Cucumber Castle, Barry and Maurice faced little in the way of blowback. (It's likely that their second foray into the cinematic world overshadowed their first since it's even more unbearably awful)

Cucumber Castle's plot of a king on his deathbed splitting his realm in two so his two sons could each rule which only caused a rift seemed to mirror that of the Bee Gees. While Robin's departure was long enough for everyone to notice, Barry and Maurice would also split from each other. It was only because of manager Robert Stigwood that the battlin' brothers would find a way back to each other with even Robin rejoining. If there were longterm solo careers to be mined from their ranks, they weren't yet ready — and, as it would turn out, they never really would be. By the time Cucumber Castle premiered on British TV, the Gibbs had managed to find their way back to one another.

The Bee Gees seemingly hadn't been away for any length of time and they were already embarking on a comeback. It would be the first of many. In the short term, it was as if they had never come apart and had never been away. "Lonely Days" was, surprisingly, their first Top 5 hit on the Billboard Hot 100 and their third number one smash on the RPM hit parade. (It did less well in Britain, being their lowest charting single since "To Love Somebody" failed to reach the Top 40 back in 1967) In retrospect, however, it may have been wise to have kept a low profile, delaying their ultimate return a few more months.

Rather than being re-energized, "Lonely Days" only confirms that this was an outfit that had run out of ideas — or, better yet, had ideas aplenty but had no idea what to do with them. Their ambition remained but the at times stirring pop of old had vanished. Cut to a trim two minutes or so it would have been a passable attempt at reviving what they once had but at nearly double that length it just becomes an irritant. A reminder that their strained relations made the Bee Gees' story was often far more interesting than much of the music they recorded. It would be a while before they'd even get back to their old mediocre ways.

Score: 3

The Stampeders: "Sweet City Woman"

August 7, 1971 (3 weeks) There have never been bands hailing out of Edmonton going by the names of either The Eskimos or The Elks. Vancouve...